Technical article 118807

I wish to use symbolic links over NFS and share the directory via AFPS.

OpenServer 5.0.4OpenServer 5.0.5OpenServer 5.0.6

Written · Last revised

Problem

Given the following scenario, I would like to export NFS directories
between two servers, symbolically link the files and share the folders
to be available for access from my Windows clients so that all files
on both servers are accessible to all.  The access needs to be
restricted so that UNIX users do not have access to all the files.

However, when I set this up, when creating folders or files in the shares causes AFPS 4.0.2 to prevent access to the share yet this works with AFPS 3.5.2n.

A walk through of an example is defined below:

This is an "almost-step-by-step" procedure to reproduce the errors that are seen.

In this example, we use directories instead of filesystems for /disk/0101 etc.

The headings "Filer01:" and "Filer02:" means that the commands have to be performed on that server.

	Filer01:
	-------
	Install a SCO OpenServer 5.0.6 Enterprise System.
	Host Name = filer01
	Domain Name = sco.com
	Standard Security Profile
	Lightweight Character Terminal Configuration.
	No Optional Software changes.
	Install Release Supplement 506a
	Install AFPS 4.0.2 as:

Primary Domain Controller (PDC) in domain "MATRIX" Remove NetBEUI protocol using netconfig NetBIOS name same as host name. NetBIOS IP address same as TCP/IP address.

Create UNIX group matrix Create UNIX user stt as member of matrix with login group matrix

	mkdir -p /disk/0101 /disk/0102 /disk/0201 /disk/0202
	Export:
		/disk/0101 and /disk/0102

Using scoadmin->filesystem allowing read-only access from all systems and read-write access from filer02.sco.com

	Add root privilege to filer02.sco.com
	Filer02:
	-------
	Install a SCO OpenServer 5.0.6 Enterprise System.
	Host Name = filer02
	Domain Name = sco.com
	Standard Security Profile
	Lightweight Character Terminal Configuration.
	No Optional Software changes.
	Install Release Supplement 506a
	Install AFPS 4.0.2 as:

Backup Domain Controller (BDC) in domain "MATRIX" Remove NetBEUI protocol using netconfig NetBIOS name same as host name. NetBIOS IP address same as TCP/IP address.

	Create UNIX group matrix

Modify /etc/passwd so that user stt will have the same user id as on filer01.

Change group membership and login group for user stt to match filer01.

	mkdir -p /disk/0101 /disk/0102 /disk/0201 /disk/0202
	Export:
		/disk/0201 and /disk/0202

using scoadmin->filesystem allowing read-only access from all systems and read-write access from filer01.sco.com

	Add root privilege to filer01.sco.com
	Filer01:
	-------
	Mount filer02.sco.com:/disk/0201 in /disk/0201
	and
	filer02.sco.com:/disk/0202 in /disk/0202
	using scoadmin->filesystem, using default settings.
	Filer02:
	-------
	Mount filer01.sco.com:/disk/0101 in /disk/0101
	and
	filer01.sco.com:/disk/0102 in /disk/0102
	using scoadmin->filesystem, using default settings.
	Filer01:
	-------
	mkdir -p /disk/0101/pro0101/doc /disk/0102/pro0102/doc
	Filer02:
	-------
	mkdir -p /disk/0201/pro0201/doc /disk/0202/pro0202/doc
	Filer01:
	-------
	mkdir /pro
	ln -s	/disk/0101/pro0101 /pro
	ln -s	/disk/0102/pro0102 /pro
	ln -s	/disk/0201/pro0201 /pro
	ln -s	/disk/0202/pro0202 /pro
	net share pro=c:/pro /remark:"Filer01 Pro Share"
	net perms c:/pro /grant "Domain Users":change
	Filer02:
	-------
	mkdir /pro
	ln -s	/disk/0101/pro0101 /pro
	ln -s	/disk/0102/pro0102 /pro
	ln -s	/disk/0201/pro0201 /pro
	ln -s	/disk/0202/pro0202 /pro
	net share pro=c:/pro /remark:"Filer02 Pro Share"
	net perms c:/pro /grant "Domain Users":change
	chmod -R 770 /disk/*
	chgrp -R matrix /disk/*
	Filer01:
	-------
	Change registry settings in AFPS:
		IgnoreUnixPermissions = 1
		UnixGroups = 1
	mapuname -a "MATRIX:Domain Users" matrix
	(The only AFPS group that AFPS user stt is a member of)
	Filer02:
	-------
	Change registry settings in AFPS:
		IgnoreUnixPermissions = 1
		UnixGroups = 1
	mapuname -a "MATRIX:Domain Users" matrix
	(The only AFPS group that AFPS user stt is a member of)
	Client01:
	--------
	Log on to a Windows workstation as user stt.
	(have seen these problems on Win98SE, WinNT4, Win2k)
	Map network drive P: to \\filer01\pro
	Map network drive K: to \\filer02\pro

Copy c:\autoexec.bat to P:\pro0101\autoexec.bat [PASS] (unix user, group and perms set correctly)

Copy c:\autoexec.bat to P:\pro0201\autoexec.bat [FAIL] (unix perms not 777)

Create new folder P:\pro0101\src [PASS] (unix user, group and perms set correctly) (however, unable to browse this newly created folder from K:)

(This next step causes loss of all access to the share) Create new folder P:\pro0201\src [FAIL] (Cannot create file when file already exists)

Change directory to any directory on P: after the above command [FAIL] (Folder was moved or removed)

This "failed state" lasts for some time, or until the SERVER service has been restarted.

Solution

This problem has been reported to SCO Engineering and as a work around it is recommended not to use symbolic links over NFS shares with AFPS.

See also

ta100067, "SCO Advanced File and Print Server permissions."

ta100046, "Group permissions are not recognized on an NFS exported AFPS share."

From the Xinuos technical article database, record 118807. Reproduced with permission. The original is at www.sco.com/ta/118807, which is reachable but blocked from search engines.

Next step

Need this fixed rather than explained?

Tell us the release, what the system runs and what it is doing. We will reply by email with what we would do next.

  • You deal with the people who do the work
  • No obligation, and no upgrade required before we will help
  • We tell you plainly if something is not worth doing

Send an enquiry

We reply by email. If a server is down, say so in the first line. You can also write to help@scoexpert.com.